Skip to content

Kentucky Sports Radio

University of Kentucky Basketball, Football, and Recruiting news brought to you in the most ridiculous manner possible.

A Pointy-Headed Intellectual Defense of Kentucky Basketball


In our continued attempt to bring you, the KSR readers, the best writers covering UK Athletics, we are adding a new slot to the rotation. Jonathan Miller is likely the most distinguished KSR poster ever in the world outside of UK Athletics. He was once the Ky State Treasurer and has spent a lifetime in and around Kentucky politics. But his life is actually more interesting than that makes him sound, because he has accomplished other tasks as well, including making the final table at an event at The World Series of Poker. He no longer is part of the political world, leaving it in the same way Matt left the legal profession (as quickly as possible). This gives him more time to focus on his other interests, such as UK basketball. He will post here on KSR on Sunday nights. His writings have been published with many national outlets and he will almost certainly use the biggest words of any writer that has ever graced this blog. We are glad to have him aboard and for your reference he is the one in the picture above on the far left

As the promise of yet another magical basketball season envelops the hills, hollers and hamlets of the Bluegrass State in a kind of euphoric delirium, the Big Blue Nation once again finds itself bracing for a deluge of outsider outrage.

It’s become an all-too-familiar scene: The pointy-headed academics and intellectuals, the cable news screaming heads, all gnashing their over-polished bridgework, complaining that Kentucky basketball embodies to them everything that is wrong with the game, indeed with college sport as a whole. The focus of special ire is head coach John Calipari, for his diabolical exploitation of rules like “one and done,” in luring susceptible teenagers with a vision of NBA fame, fortune and celebrity, if only they join his unsavory cabal. The righteous guardians of the Athenian ideal of amateur student athletics loudly decrying the vulgar capitalist reality…in the form of a collection of mostly African-American young men representing one of the nation’s poorest states.

In this, my virgin splash into the KSR waters, I must reveal my not-so-secret identity:

I’m one of them.

Yes, I’m Jonathan, and I’m a recovering politician.

And I’m a card-carrying member of the pretentious fraternity of self-important geeks who never could have pledged a fraternity…with an overpriced education and a lengthy series of wonky op-ed columns, mouthy TV talk show appearances and highfalutin policy books under my belt. I’ve spent two decades walking in their corridors of power, kibitzing in their green rooms, eating their cocktail party heavy hors d’oeuvres.

Of course, many of their gripes with college hoops are quite legitimate. From the economic exploitation of teenage athletes, to the shady shoe contracts secured by its plutocratic coaches, to the blatantly unfair and hypocritical NCAA governance regime — big-time, big-money college roundball leaves many the casual fan with a guilty hangover after the last shimmy of the Big Dance in April.

But the knee-jerk, broad-brushed condemnation of Kentucky basketball emerges from a separate, more intimate truth: Since middle school, much of my kind – the jump shot-challenged intelligentsia, that is – have scoffed at the popularity, coddling, and public financing of the jock culture. College is our sacred realm – for academics, scholarship and research, not professional sports-grooming.

However, in rooting against the team that has mastered the flawed system, the critics are missing a greater truth: The keys to fixing the sport’s soul can be found precisely in the qualities that make Kentucky basketball so special. For while cerebral baseball and primal football continue to be heralded as our national pastimes; college basketball, particularly here in the heartland, really does matter.

At its core, basketball is the most populist and egalitarian of major sports. Its character derives in part from its tiny barriers to entry–all you need is a ball and a hoop to practice alone, and a bona fide game can be played with just a pal or a small group of friends. While its complex choreography and mosaic interpersonal psychodynamics are often underestimated, basketball is the simplest game to understand and appreciate. Ball goes into basket; your team scores. A contest’s time is precise and limited; its court dimensions, clear and uniform: As Gene Hackman famously proved in Hoosiers, the rim is always exactly ten feet from the ground whether at an urban playground or in a professional arena.

Basketball is also the ultimate spectator sport. Unlike radio-friendly baseball or HDTV-enhanced football, hoops are best enjoyed in person. With much, much less downtime than the Big Two, basketball games are filled with relentless exhibitions of artistry in action–colorful feats of intensely-rehearsed talent and gravity-defying acrobatics, while the participants remain in near constant motion. Because the vertical plane is regularly pierced, only basketball can provide those rare, sublime moments of transcendental grace. The courtside crowd isn’t distracted by the weather, organ player, food, bands, or tailgating: Until the final buzzer sounds, the game itself is the only thing that matters.

Whether in a high school gym or a professional arena, the game is played indoors, the fans on top of the action, literally involved in the hum and flow of the game, the most intimate among the major sports. In a game in which improvised and instinctual play is the norm, where fatigue and self-confidence are critical to performance, an enlivened and vocal crowd can provide enormous emotional and psychological comfort to the home squad, or can harass and dispirit the visitors. A home crowd–particularly at the college or high school level–becomes, for a few hours at least, a cohesive, interdependent community: Fans who might disagree sharply on matters of politics, religion, lifestyle, or just about any topic, join voices in passionate advocacy of their squad, or, almost as often, in intense criticism of the referees. It’s no coincidence that in many rural communities, most community-building events–graduation ceremonies, formal dances, citizen forums–take place in the high school gym.

Indeed — warning: be prepared for some real wonk-dom — a potent communitarian strand of populism is modeled in the game itself. Bill Simmons’ bestseller, The Book of Basketball, reads in places like a Michael Sandel philosophy lecture or a 1968 Bobby Kennedy campaign speech: “The secret of basketball is that it’s not about basketball…Teams only win titles when their best players forget about statistics, sublimate their own games for the greater good and put their egos on hold.” And the greatest of the greats – Jordan, Magic, Bird – only earned their iconic status after they learned to surrender their own self-interest (high scoring averages) for the common good (winning championships), a noteworthy lesson in unselfishness and the Golden Rule for the boys, girls, and grownups who consider these hardwood heroes role models.

There’s been no better example of this phenomenon than last year’s Kentucky Wildcat squad. Heralded last year as the best recruiting class in the history of college basketball, the freshmen-dominated Wildcat team suffered through a disappointing regular season – falling from number one in the preseason polls to out of the top 25 by season’s end. Undeniably, these teenage phenoms were extraordinarily talented individual ballers, but they simply weren’t gelling as a cohesive unit. It wasn’t until postseason that they learned to overcome their stereotypically-Millenneal narcissism and played selfless ball. And as a result, they shocked their way to the NCAA Championship game and emerged as one of the most beloved teams in the long, long lore of the blue and white tradition.

It’s no wonder then why college hoops have made such a remarkable and substantive impact on education at the University of Kentucky. The administration understands that many Kentucky families – especially those in the most remote, economically-depressed areas of the state – dream of sending their kids to UK, and it has leveraged roundball prowess to help market and fund all of its major academic initiatives and capital campaigns, including its ambitious long-term effort to transform the school into a Top 20 public research university. And while it’s an unusual, although not a unique, collegiate example, UK basketball not only sustains itself financially; but along with football, its profits help enable the athletic department – with 20 other sports teams—- to pay for itself, plus provide millions of dollars to the school for non-athletic scholarships

There’s also been perhaps no force more powerful for racial fence-mending, at least here in the South. A half century since UK’s all-white “Rupp’s Runts” lost the national championship to Texas Western’s history-making all-black starting lineup – the whitest of all southern states has fallen in love with a series of teams composed almost entirely of African-American teenagers. We’ve reveled in their soul swagger and hip-hop sentimentality — few Kentuckians will ever forget how to perform the “John Wall Dance,” the shimmy sensation of the winter of 2009-10.

That craze prompted another elite African-American point guard to enter Kentucky lore that February when he stood at Rupp Arena’s center court to perform a hallowed ritual of the Big Blue Nation:  After a group of cheerleaders contorted their bodies on the hardwood floor to spell out the first seven letters of the state’s name, Earvin “Magic” Johnson lifted his arms high into the air, and became, for one shining moment, the living embodiment of the letter “Y.” The “Y” tradition borders on a holy sacrament in Kentucky; the modern equivalent of a high priest standing in the middle of the Great Temple, reaching toward the heavens, bringing the blue-attired congregation to its feet and lifting the faithful into frenzied spiritual revival.

But Johnson added a special touch:  The legend smoothly transitioned his right arm into a John Wall Dance.  The crowd erupted into an authentic, communal embrace of pure joy, radiating off of Magic’s trademark supernova smile.  Johnson has no roots in the state, nor any connection to the team, but his gesture united two generations of basketball lovers, and it provided a bond that transcended our differences.  That, sports fans, defines populism. And it articulated, without words, why college basketball matters.

Earlier that afternoon, in the State Capitol Rotunda, Magic had waded through the friendliest of mobs–mostly white, the crowd slowly jostling forward, lunging for an autograph, photograph, or simply to touch the towering African-American.  A few feet away, the statues of Civil War adversaries Abraham Lincoln and Jefferson Davis stood in stark repose; in their time, that same scene would have conveyed a far different meaning.


It’s this religious connection between our culture and the games that we love that will be the focus of this column every Sunday night. I’ll share my thoughts on how society can help fix the problems inherent in sport, and how sport can help fix the problems inherent in society. And I will be holding our key institutions — whether the NCAA, the NFL or the Congress — to the same standards that are modeled on the court and imitated by the fan base: equality, selflessness, and community.

Kentucky basketball truly reflects American values. And it’s high time that the rest of us followed its example.

(This essay includes excerpts of musings previously published at

Article written by Jonathan Miller

Jonathan Miller, The Recovering Politician (Twitter: @RecoveringPol), writes about the politics of sport and the sport of politics...and sometimes about bourbon. Jonathan has been elected twice as Kentucky's State Treasurer; practices as a crisis management attorney; authored three books on faith, public policy and crisis management; serves as a Contributor to The Daily Beast, played straight man on The Daily Show with Jon Stewart; reached the final table of the World Series of Poker; and with his summer camp sweetheart, raised two remarkable twenty-something daughters.

51 Comments for A Pointy-Headed Intellectual Defense of Kentucky Basketball

  1. PhilUK18
    8:08 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    I presume it’s meant to read “he’s the one on the far RIGHT in the picture”. Because the one on the far left looks a lot like Magic Johnson to me haha. Other than that small editorial issue, excellent article by you, Mr. Miller. I’ll be very interested to read more in the future.

    • nybrasky
      8:24 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

      The sarcasm font must not have come through on your computer.

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:46 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

      Thanks for the compliment! I’ve never been told that I look like Magic before, but I can now see the resemblance. At least I don’t look like that dweeb on the far right.

    • PhilUK18
      9:03 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

      Nybrasky- Yeah, I guess my phone lost the sarcasm font reader in the upgrade to iOS 8. Screw you, Apple.

  2. rainman
    8:25 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    Rule #1- If it’s too long we won’t read it!

    • rainman
      8:26 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

      Or at least I wont!

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:47 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

      I stopped reading your comment after “it’s”

      Sorry, short attention sp

    8:29 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    Welcome to KSR Jonathon…and a misspelling right from the get go…”big-time, bi-money college roundball”…you are trying way too hard to fit in around here:))

    Unless of course you are talking about huge sums paid to the NCAA from bi-sexuals, but I didn’t get that from the context.

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:48 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

      Good catch: I was trying to make an inclusive, embracing comment about all peoples, being the left-wing loony that I am.

  4. DT in DC
    8:29 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    Was his mom a political science professor at UK? I think I had her for a class in the mid-90s.

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:50 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

      Yes, indeed, my mom taught poli sci for two decades at UK.

      Although I was warned about commentors who claimed to have had my mom.

  5. BigBlueSkyDog
    8:34 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    An interesting read for the most part but why bring up the black vs. white angle continually with the 1966 Texas Western game? It’s been fifty years for crying out loud! Why not mention that Rupp recruited both Wes Unseld and Butch Beard and very nearly signed both? Rupp was hated and reviled for daring to suggest that the SEC integrate. It should also be noted that Rupp signed his first African-American player before Bear Bryant at Alabama.

    In short, you don’t sound so much like a pointy-headed intellectual as you sound like a broken record.

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:52 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

      Very true about how about Rupp’s image has been mischaracterized and hyperbolized, especially in the rear-view mirror.

  6. Matt Jones
    8:34 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    #2 I want Jonathan’s articles to be long and good…if you don’t want to read them, that is more than fine. But don’t presume to speak for all the site’s readers (as the amount of hits the article has alread gotten showcase) based on your own predisposition to not have the attention span to finish

    • theWilkman
      11:20 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      The best articles on KSR (besides the comedic gold generously given to us by C.M. Tomlin) are the longer, thought-provoking pieces you won’t find anywhere else. This is a great start to your KSR career, Jonathan, I’m looking forward to reading many more.

  7. rainman
    8:42 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    OK, Rule #1, I wont read it if it’s too long!
    Hows that?
    I didn’t fully read yours either!

  8. downebri
    8:51 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    Great column Jonathan!! You bring a unique perspective to this website and UK fandom. I’m looking forward to reading more of your work!

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:53 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

      Thanks. I hope a few readers have half as much fun reading my pieces as I will writing them.

  9. wu slang
    8:52 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    I don’t agree with Miller’s politics, but this was a good read. It’s good to have new voices, especially when basketball ends and the UK sports news is slow coming out.

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:55 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

      Thanks, Wu. Now that I’m out of the arena, I have found myself disagreeing with some of my politics as well. I bet we find a couple of things to agree about on this site.

  10. millertime98
    9:07 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    The only thing the length of the article did was make me think this is turning into Grantland-KSR…and I’m all for it! Welcome and congrats. Just know that if you are at a remote show people might be told not to clap for you because of your politics!

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:39 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      I will be sure to wear a bullet proof vest at any live shows. And keep my mouth shut about my views on marriage equality.

  11. Bullitt County UK fan
    9:10 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    That was beautiful.

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:39 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      Thanks — college basketball is a beautiful sport that deserves the kind of poetic waxing that is usually reserved for baseball.

  12. scwhite9
    9:18 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    Actually, I really loved your article and look forward to more. This will minimize some of the stalkers on here who won’t be able to read the big words. Look forward to more each week.

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:40 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      I’m looking forward to the stalkers. The only thing I miss about me being in politics

  13. Duuuuuude
    9:19 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    Looking forward to hearing more. You must be one of those sesquipedalians.

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:41 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      Duuuude, you need to see Bad Words with Jason Bateman if you are going to use words like that. Pretty hilarious.

    • Duuuuuude
      2:22 pm October 27, 2014 Permalink

      Well, I married one. I will take her to see the movie on your recommendation. Glad we have a full service contributor!

  14. Wildcat13
    9:22 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    It was nice reading an intellectual, in-depth article … and some say Kentucky Fans are wacko! Loved it!!!

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:41 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      The Big Blue Nation is definitely wacko. That’s why I fit in so well.

  15. soggyUKgrad
    9:30 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    Great read Jonathan!!! With your background from Harvard Law, and Matt’s background from Duke Law, I would love to hear what you guys might think would be a fair punishment for UNC’s 18 year academic cheating scandal.

  16. chief_cat
    9:48 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    Terrific read! As a life-long UK fan and retired Navy chief now living miles from home in Maryland, I find myself constantly trying to explain the phenomenon of Kentucky basketball. My friends and neighbors don’t understand why we natives of the Bluegrass adore our Cats as we do. I have come to realize it is more than the love of a sport, player, team, coach or university. it is rather the sum of the parts steeped in tradition and lore that precedes us. Our fandom is a part of our DNA.

    We rally around our love for the Cats. Las you so eloquently stated, this love transcends political, economic, social, racial, religious and geographical differences. Moreover, it provides us with hopes, dreams, possibilities, and, more often than not, with tangible forms of satisfaction (see eight banners and endless bragging rights).

    I have off wondered if this passion was borne out of a need for a bright and shining ray of hope in what was a rather austere reality in Kentucky about the time that Adolph Rupp took the helm in Lexington. While much of the country was in full recovery mode after the Great Depression and WWII, Kentucky wasn’t faring as well. Our grandparents and great-grandparents were looked down upon by outsiders. We were hillbillies, relics, and ignorant in their eyes. When Adolph’s teams started winning in a big way and the national spotlight shone on My Old Kentucky Home, we found something for which we could be proud. We were better than everyone else at something. An entire state turned its eyes toward Alumni Gym and the blue and white clad Cats and we’ve never looked back.

    I have always felt our passion for Kentucky basketball originated from those humble beginnings and has grown to the global phenomenon that is the BBN. I would enjoy reading your opinion as well as other writers on KSR, as well as fans who frequent the site.

    Again, welcome Jonathan. I look forward to your musings.

    • Wildcat13
      10:17 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

      TOUCHE’ …. Definitely in our DNA, of which we have no control … and we like it that way!

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:43 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      Well said. I was too young for the Rupp years (actually graduated Henry Clay with his grandson, Chip), but my dad always waxed about the influence of the team on state pride.

  17. Tomasito
    10:23 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    Enjoyed your stuff man. I really like the direction KSR is going. Getting rid of the crazy commenters was the first step. I listen to the radio show and check the website every day but was having to go to other sites to communicate with fellow fans because of the cess pool that was KSR comment section. Adding someone who will offer a different perspective is just icing on the cake. Keep up the good work.

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:44 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      Thanks — I’m a big fan of how the Internet has democratized public debate, but anonymous trolling can grow weary at times. Hopefully, we can transcend that here.

  18. Zack
    10:52 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    Im just glad to have a writer who will actually communicate with us on here.. although I doubt he will keep this up.

    • Juan4UK
      8:22 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      Tyler T used to be good about that.

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:45 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      I hope I can keep it up! Interacting is the fun part.

  19. Zack
    11:13 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    After seeing that this guy is actually interacting with us fans I went back and read the whole article, and I have to say.. It is great. I cant wait to see what else this guy brings to the table. Kentucky basketball is more than just a game.. Its a way of life.

  20. Capt. Ragnar
    11:32 pm October 26, 2014 Permalink

    Well done. Undoubtedly, some will first disparage without reading based upon your “left-wing” roots. Although most of what I see within the comments has been very positive. I for one, welcome the cerebral process by which you attempt to blend addressing issues of the day related through a mutual appreciation for the “Cayts”.

    Politics on this site is typically a disaster, as few are able to register a cogent response to the most basic refrain without resorting to hyperbole/talking points/name calling. We’ll differ in opinion in some regards, hopefully agree on others, joined in fandom regardless. A welcomed addition. Looking forward to future post.

    • Juan4UK
      8:21 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      You might like A Sea of Blue

    • Capt. Ragnar
      8:34 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      You made a pun…

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:46 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      Thanks Capt.! Hopefully those of us who want to have a meaningful dialogue can do so here, and just shut out the haters.

  21. Casper
    1:52 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

    Short paragraphs are easier to read, just saying.

  22. Juan4UK
    8:19 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

    Introductions by: #Humblebrag

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:46 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      I don’t think there is anything humble about my bragging. #bragbrag

  23. oldawgblue
    8:25 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

    A good read. Combining Miller’s cerebral approach with Drew Franklin’s sense of the absurd, and Matt’s unerring sense of the “tacky” gives the site a much broader appeal. Those of us who acquired our knowledge of and love for UK Basketball through nights gathered around the Philco are beginning to die off, and it’s heartening for us to know that the communal/tribal/family aspect of UK Basketball is not being lost in the 21st century.

    • Jonathan Miller
      8:47 am October 27, 2014 Permalink

      Thanks — one of the great things I love about my home state is the sense of community, particularly around basketball games. Helps make up for all of the problems we face.